I am just not a fan of water based finishes.....thin, odd coloring on dark woods at times, brittle, inflexible. Just not as rich. I do get the reason people want to use water based, easy cleanup, low VOC etc. How many yachts and sailboats have their brightwork finished in water based material?? I think really is a question of personal preference and intended usage. All the countertops and Lagun top in my van are sapele with four coats Helmsman spar varnish.....I am from Maine and its what we use in the boat building community, that or Epifanes.