Nautamaran
2004 140” HRC 2500 (Crewed)
Not that anyone has asked... There are tradeoffs between a crossover connection (acr or solenoid) and a Bat-to-bat (B2B) charger.
Dick alluded earlier to the concept of “charging profiles” when he said your AGM battery would need topping off, and anyone contemplating adding an Aux battery would be well advised to read up on the concept. The condensed version is that different batteries have different charging needs, so pairing different batteries with a single charging source will fail to meet the needs of one of those battery types. An extreme example would be pairing LiFePO with a Lead-acid battery: the voltage differences alone make it a bad idea, but LiFePO batteries are destroyed by over-charging, while lead-acid require a maintenance trickle current to stay at 100%. The variations aren’t this extreme when combining flooded lead-acid, gell-cells, or AGM types, but these still have different preferred voltage and current preferences.
Enter the B2B charge controller: this is a device that takes energy from one source (usually an alternator, but can be anything) and uses it to supply a charging current to a bank of batteries based on its type and state of charge. That last bit is important, as it has a direct impact on recharge times and how long your system will go before your battery needs replacement. You will care a lot more about this when managing a bank of $2,000 lithium cells, but it’s still worth knowing with a $200 AGM battery, though it may not justify the premium cost of a B2B charger.
Part of the charging profile of any battery is the “bulk” phase, during which the current is limited to an upper boundary specified by the manufacturer. This is as fast as the chemical reaction can go, and exceeding it may damage the cell, particularly with sealed lead-acid batteries like gell and AGM. Joining the (+) terminals of batteries is an option only when they are of similar chemistry and construction, and at a similar voltage, otherwise the inrush current can exceed the profile current. So this is another factor in favour of a B2B charger, but as a rule of thimb, if you keep the aux battery voltage within one volt of the engine battery this never becomes an issue, and a solar or shorepiwer setup can keep the aux battery topped up.
A crossover switch wins in simplicity, price, and current capacity. You also can’t pull power backwards through (most) B2B chargers, so they won’t allow the engine to crank from the aux battery. Nor will a small B2B flow enough current to keep up with a big drain on the aux battery, so if you’re heating a casserole in the microwave and you want to pull 150 amps through the inverter for half an hour, you’ll want a crossover switch available in the system so you can meet that demand using the 200 amp engine alternator rather than pulling it from your aux bank (you probably also want a 24 volt system, but that’s another topic). But if your aux battery is anything but a flooded lead-acid battery, the engine alternator will not be capable of maintaining a 100% charge, and will never push up into the desulfurization voltages required for full lifespan, so the solar or shore power charger will need to perform that duty.
Have fun out there,
-dave
Dick alluded earlier to the concept of “charging profiles” when he said your AGM battery would need topping off, and anyone contemplating adding an Aux battery would be well advised to read up on the concept. The condensed version is that different batteries have different charging needs, so pairing different batteries with a single charging source will fail to meet the needs of one of those battery types. An extreme example would be pairing LiFePO with a Lead-acid battery: the voltage differences alone make it a bad idea, but LiFePO batteries are destroyed by over-charging, while lead-acid require a maintenance trickle current to stay at 100%. The variations aren’t this extreme when combining flooded lead-acid, gell-cells, or AGM types, but these still have different preferred voltage and current preferences.
Enter the B2B charge controller: this is a device that takes energy from one source (usually an alternator, but can be anything) and uses it to supply a charging current to a bank of batteries based on its type and state of charge. That last bit is important, as it has a direct impact on recharge times and how long your system will go before your battery needs replacement. You will care a lot more about this when managing a bank of $2,000 lithium cells, but it’s still worth knowing with a $200 AGM battery, though it may not justify the premium cost of a B2B charger.
Part of the charging profile of any battery is the “bulk” phase, during which the current is limited to an upper boundary specified by the manufacturer. This is as fast as the chemical reaction can go, and exceeding it may damage the cell, particularly with sealed lead-acid batteries like gell and AGM. Joining the (+) terminals of batteries is an option only when they are of similar chemistry and construction, and at a similar voltage, otherwise the inrush current can exceed the profile current. So this is another factor in favour of a B2B charger, but as a rule of thimb, if you keep the aux battery voltage within one volt of the engine battery this never becomes an issue, and a solar or shorepiwer setup can keep the aux battery topped up.
A crossover switch wins in simplicity, price, and current capacity. You also can’t pull power backwards through (most) B2B chargers, so they won’t allow the engine to crank from the aux battery. Nor will a small B2B flow enough current to keep up with a big drain on the aux battery, so if you’re heating a casserole in the microwave and you want to pull 150 amps through the inverter for half an hour, you’ll want a crossover switch available in the system so you can meet that demand using the 200 amp engine alternator rather than pulling it from your aux bank (you probably also want a 24 volt system, but that’s another topic). But if your aux battery is anything but a flooded lead-acid battery, the engine alternator will not be capable of maintaining a 100% charge, and will never push up into the desulfurization voltages required for full lifespan, so the solar or shore power charger will need to perform that duty.
Have fun out there,
-dave